arrow-down
Home » Selling Guides » Autographed Memorabilia

Is Your Autographed Baseball Worth $100,000? How to Sell Autographed Sports Memorabilia

autographed sports memorabilia selling guide

Flipsy.com shows you how to find the value of your autographed sports memorabilia and where to sell it for top dollar in the definitive guide to selling autographed baseballs, jerseys, helmets, bats, and more

Do you want to sell an autographed baseball or other sports memorabilia? Autographed memorabilia can be worth hundreds, thousands, or even hundreds of thousands of dollars. Find out how much your autographed sports memorabilia is worth and where to sell it in Flipsy.com’s definitive guide.

Our guide to selling autographed sports memorabilia includes:

  • The world’s most valuable autographed sports memorabilia
  • What makes autographed sports memorabilia valuable?
  • How much is your autographed sports memorabilia worth?
  • Where to sell autographed sports memorabilia
  • Autographed sports memorabilia selling tips

Follow this expert advice to find the value of your autographed sports memorabilia and sell it for the most money.

The world’s most valuable autographed sports memorabilia

The highest auction price ever paid for signed sports memorabilia was the $4.3 million paid in 2010 for the original copy of James Naismith’s “13 Rules of Basketball,” penned in 1891 and signed by Naismith in 1931.

That $4.3 million price tag is more than a half-million dollars more than the $3.7 million paid at the same auction for a copy of the Emancipation Proclamation signed by Abraham Lincoln.

Some of the highest auction prices paid for autographed sports memorabilia include:

ITEMPRICEYEAR SOLDAUCTION HOUSE
Babe Ruth bat (first home run in old Yankee Stadium$1.265 million2004Sotheby’s/SCP Auctions
 

Babe Ruth 1918 Red Sox contract$1.020 million2014Goldin Auctions
 

Babe Ruth 1920 Yankees contract$996,0002005Sotheby’s/SCP Auctions
 

Babe Ruth 1933 All-Star Game home run ball$805,0002006Major League Baseball FanFest memorabilia auction – Hunt Auctions
 
Hank Aaron 755th home run ball$655,0001999Guernsey’s Auction House
 

Joe Jackson game bat$583,0002016Christie’s Auction House
 

Kirk Gibson 1988 World Series Game 1 bat$575,9122010SCP Auctions
 

Muhammad Ali-signed gloves from 1965 Sonny Liston “Phantom Punch” bout$956,0002015Heritage Auctions
 

 

Muhammad Ali/Cassius Clay handwritten letter confirming conversion to Islam (1964)$131,4502016Heritage Auctions
 

 

Wilt Chamberlain 1965-66 game-worn 76ers jersey$97,5002017Heritage Auctions
 

Michael Jordan 1984 Olympic Finals game-worn Converse shoes, U.S. gold victory over Spain$190,3722017SCP Auctions
 

 

Stephen Curry 2016 NBA Finals Games 4 & 6 Golden State Warriors road jersey$57,6002017Goldin Auctions
 

 

2003-2004 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection LeBron James 1/1 rookie card$312,0002017Goldin Auctions
 

 

1986 World Series Game 6 Bill Buckner glove$104,4002017Goldin Auctions
 

Lou Gehrig/Babe Ruth dual-signed 1939 photo from Lou Gehrig Appreciation Day$120,0002007Sotheby’s Auction House
 

 

Joe DiMaggio & Marilyn Monroe signed baseball$191,2002006Heritage Auctions
 

Basketball signed by Michael Jordan and Michael Jackson from “Jam” music video$294,0002010Julien’s Auctions
 

 

Bum Phillips Houston Oilers helmet$2 million2011Charity auction held in Beaumont, Texas
 

Bobby Orr rookie jersey$115,0002008Heritage Auctions
 

1935 National Chicle Bronko Nagurski trading card$350,0002011Private transaction
 

Have a phone to sell? Trust verified stores compete to offer 30% more than carrier trade-in programs. Find out how much yours is worth.

iPhone Samsung Sony
ZTE HTC More Androids

Baseball is king when it comes to valuable autographed sports memorabilia; and for many collectors, the “holy grail” of autographed sports memorabilia is a baseball signed by Babe Ruth, says Rich Altman, owner and operator of Hollywood Collectibles in Dania Beach, Florida.

For example, one Bambino-signed ball sold for $388,375 in 2012.

“Great Ruth signatures are a holy grail,” says Leila Dunbar, president of Leila Dunbar Appraisals, “because, even though they are not rare as he ushered in the age of signing. Ruth’s feats as a pitcher and slugger have transcended sports and generations and his is the most sought athlete autograph today.”

Rules of Baseball

James Naismith signed rules of basketball. Source: Sotheby’s

Autographs from 19th-century Hall of Fame players such as Cap Anson, and early 20th century Hall of Famers Christy Mathewson, who passed away in 1925, are rare and very difficult to obtain; so they can be worth tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands, depending on the player.

“The most valuable signed sports memorabilia are signed game-used items, such as Babe Ruth’s homerun ball from the very first All-Star Game in 1933, which sold for $800,000 in 2006,” says Dunbar. “These are valued more for the historical event and/or player they represent than they are for the signature itself. Another example is the ball that went through Bill Buckner’s legs in Game 6 of the 1986 World Series, which was signed by Mookie Wilson and sold in 2012 for $493,000. Or, they are pristine signatures, such as a 9.5-graded baseball signed by Ruth, which sold for $388,000 in 2012.”

What makes autographed sports memorabilia valuable?

Several factors dictate how much autographed sports memorabilia is worth, including:

  • Signature quality and condition
  • Rarity and desirability
  • Historical importance and player legacy
  • Provenance and authenticity

Let’s take a closer look at each.

Signature quality and condition

“Condition affects value significantly,” says Dunbar. “The stronger the signature and the better the condition of the piece, then usually the higher the value.”

Appraisal companies such as PSA/DNA, Beckett, SGC, and JSA grade on a ten-point scale as follows:

GRADEDESCRIPTION
Gem Mint (GEM-MT): 10Flawless with a strong signature
Mint (MINT): 9May only have one very minor flaw
Near Mint-Mint (NM-MT): 8May have one or two very minor flaws
Near Mint (NM): 7Slight wear or fraying
Excellent-Mint (EX-MT): 6Minor wear or fraying
Excellent (EX): 5Wear and scratches that do not detract from appearance
Very Good-Excellent (VG-EX): 4Modest wear and light scratching
Very Good (VG): 3Wear and light scratching, slight discoloration
Good (GOOD): 2Obvious wear, scratching, discoloration, or stains
Fair (FR): 1.5Considerable wear
Poor (PR): 1Extreme wear, missing pieces, tears, etc.

Half-point grades are assigned to pieces that are in better than average condition for a particular grade, yet not quite enough to warrant the next-highest grade.

It’s important to note that autographed memorabilia can hold significant value even if it has a low condition grade.

“A game-used baseball would have more value than a new baseball, if the ball was significant to a certain player that signed that ball,” says Altman. “For example, if Mike Trout signed a game-used ball that he hit a homerun with, it would sell for much more than a baseball that was brand-new.”

Dunbar concurs: “Often, memorabilia signed during a player’s career is more highly-valued than post-career, as it is rarer and it may not be in as good condition, which can cancel out.”

Rarity and desirability

Rare autographed sports memorabilia generally command higher price tags, such as is the case with Anson and Mathewson signatures, but that’s not a hard-and-fast rule; desirability can make even non-rare items valuable (and, conversely, rare pieces that have little desirability have little value).

“Even though his autograph isn’t rare, Ruth is the most sought-after of all signatures, with signatures selling from the low thousands into the hundreds of thousands for large, strong signatures on pristine baseballs, with great provenance and/or a fantastic story,” says Dunbar.

Babe Ruth autographed baseball

1933 All Star Game ball signed by Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig. Source: Heritage Auctions

The rarest signatures are often by players who passed away before the age of signing shows, which began in the 1980’s, says Dunbar.

“Many player signatures from the 1980’s are generally worth $5-75. Legendary Hall of Famers who passed way in the late 1990’s to early 2000’s such as Mickey Mantle, Ted Williams, Joe DiMaggio, and David Ortiz generally sell from $200-$1,000,” she says.  “Most contemporary players or those recently retired are worth $5-$75, with a few exceptions such as Derek Jeter and David Ortiz, who sell in the low to mid hundreds. Those who passed away prior to the 1980’s are much scarcer and more sought-after, including Jackie Robinson, Ty Cobb, Christy Mathewson, and Walter Johnson, which can sell into the thousands to tens of thousands and for the best of the best, into six figures.”

Historical importance and legacy

Autographed memorabilia that has historical significance is often the most valuable and valued more for its historical importance than for the autograph itself. An item can be historically significant if it was involved in a famous game or marks a major milestone, such as the ball that went through Bill Buckner’s legs.

The legacy of a player, team, or event likewise affects value.

“Ruth’s signed player contracts have sold in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, up to more than $1,000,000 for his 1918 Red Sox contract and $2.3 million for one of the three copies of the 1919 contract that sold Ruth from the Red Sox to the Yankees,” says Dunbar.

signed Ali gloves

“Phantom Punch” bout gloves signed by Muhammad Ali. Source: Heritage Auctions

Provenance and authenticity

Provenance, defined as the history of ownership, might be compared to the chain of custody in a police investigation. The more that is known about a given piece of autographed memorabilia, the more valuable it can be – especially if its provenance is significant and verifiable.

Remember the ball that went through Bill Buckner’s legs and later sold for nearly half a million dollars? The ball had the provenance of being taken from the game by right field umpire Ed Montague and was given to Mets traveling secretary Arthur Richman, who had Mookie Wilson sign and inscribe it, says Dunbar, who also recounts the provenance of the ball in one of baseball’s most famous stories.

“In 2014, Grey Flannel Auctions sold a baseball signed and inscribed by Ruth to Johnny Sylvester, a boy to whom Ruth promised to hit a homer for him after he found out Sylvester was in the hospital. Ruth did, in Game 4 of the 1926 World Series,” she says. “The ball came from the family and included photos of Ruth and Sylvester.”

autographed Wilt Chamberlain jersey

Signed Wilt Chamberlain jersey. Source: Heritage Auctions

The ability to verify the authenticity of your autographed memorabilia is critical to maximizing its value. This can be done by having your memorabilia inspected by a company such as Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) or James Spence Authentication (JSA), which will then issue a Letter of Authenticity (LOA).

“No third-party authentication company is going to be perfect, but PSA and JSA have large libraries of known authentic exemplars which they use to determine authenticity and are generally considered to be the industry standard and are used by most of the major auction houses,” says Dunbar. “If you are buying an autograph, you want to make sure you either have an LOA from them or that the provenance is ironclad, such as you are getting it directly from the player himself.”

Authentication is important because buyers need to protect themselves from forgeries. Dunbar says there are two types of forgeries: those that were done by clubhouse attendances (such as Pete Sheehy of the Yankees), secretaries, or relatives at a time when autographs had little value and demand far outstripped supply; and forgeries made specifically to make money.

“Back in 1999 the FBI ran a sting called ‘Operation Bullpen’ where they caught a forger on the West Coast,” she says. “They estimate $100 million worth of phony signatures went into the pipeline.”

How much is your autographed sports memorabilia worth?

Your autographed sports memorabilia is worth whatever a buyer will pay for it, and it’s possible you have an exceedingly rare, highly-desirable, and very valuable piece. However, most autographed items do not sell for tens of thousands of dollars.

“The average price of autographed sports memorabilia ranges varies greatly,” says Altman. “Lower-end autographed items can sell for as low as $5, where high-end items can sell for hundreds of thousands of dollars.”

“The retail range from dealers is $25 to $2,500 for autographs from the past 40 years. The auction range is $10 to $1,000, as collectors know that a lot of Hall of Famers’ signatures are easily obtainable,” says Dunbar. “Bob Feller, Yogi Berra, Stan Musial, Pee Wee Reese, DiMaggio, Williams, Mantle, Frank and Brooks Robinson, Willie Mays, Hank Arron, Willie McCovey; all can sell between $50 and $500 at auction, unless it is a rare inscription from Mantle such as ‘Happy Birthday’ or ‘Merry Christmas,’ which can sell in the low thousands.”

Here’s how to tell how much your autographed memorabilia is worth:

Google it

“Google is a good first step,” says Dunbar. “If you type in ‘Willie Mays signed baseball,’ you will see several come up from retail sites, which gives you an idea of that market.”

Consult guides

You can subscribe to pricing guides such as Beckett’s Sports Cards and Collectibles Price Guide (online) and Sports Market Report (print) to review the book value of your items, says Altman.

Check Ebay

Search for your item on Ebay and check “sold listings” in the left sidebar to see how much people have legitimately paid for similar items. Make sure you examine listings to be sure what you’re selling is comparable.

Ask your local dealer

“Your local card shop may be willing to take a look at a collection and give an appraisal of value,” says Altman. Search online to find local card shops and memorabilia dealers.

Check past auctions

Dunbar says you can check auction values for similar items via free databases provided by auction companies. You’ll need to register first. Companies that offer free databases include:

Get it appraised

Finally, you can have your autographed sports memorabilia appraised by an authority in the industry. Autographed sports memorabilia appraisers include:

You can also find sports memorabilia appraisers through the International Society of Appraisers, Appraisers Association of America, and the American Society of Appraisers websites.

Here are some example prices for autographed sports memorabilia recently sold on Ebay:

AUTOGRAPHED SPORTS MEMORABILIAEBAY SOLD PRICE
Tom Brady game-used jersey patch$8,489
Mickey Mantle autographed bat$2,250
Michael Jordan Upper Deck card$1,450
Framed Pele 1970 football/soccer shirt$465
Baseball bat signed by 35+ Hall of Famers$500
Muhammad Ali boxing glove$225
Joe Montana Donruss card$280
Peyton Manning football$220
1957 Detroit Lions team-signed championship ball$187
Joe Frazier boxing glove$125
1922 Yankees team-signed baseball$12,174
Lou Gehrig baseball$12,100
1927 Babe Ruth baseball$6,994
Mickey Mantle/Roger Maris dual signed baseball$3,999
Jimmie Foxx baseball$2,300
1962 Don Drysdale/Cy Young dual signed baseball$1,495
Roy Halladay baseball$500
Joe DiMaggio baseball$250
George Brett baseball$150
Sandy Koufax baseball$120
Nolan Ryan baseball$55
Lou Piniella baseball$20
Tom Glavine baseball$10
Lou Holtz Notre Dame mini helmet$80
Jerry Rice Leaf trading card$159
Tiger Woods 2013 Bridgestone golf ball$296
Zdeno Charo Boston Bruins hockey puck$110
Magic Johnson basketball$60

 

Find the value of your Samsung phone

Galaxy S9 Plus Galaxy S9 Galaxy Note 8
Galaxy Note S8 Plus Galaxy S8 More Samsungs

Where to sell autographed sports memorabilia

Now that you have a general understanding of how much autographed sports memorabilia is worth, you can confidently sell yours and know you’re getting a fair deal. Here are some autographed sports memorabilia selling options, including pros, cons, and reviews (where available).

Sports memorabilia auction houses

If you have a highly-valuable item or collection of sports memorabilia, an auction house can help you sell it for top dollar. Most auction houses will help verify the authenticity of your autographed sports memorabilia (often via partnerships with third-party authenticators), market the item to attract bidders, and handle the entire sale. They can also help you set a reserve price.

Many auction houses host both online and offline auctions in multiple formats: live, timed, absentee, phone, catalog, floor, etc.

Fees vary by auction house: buyer’s premiums (which are paid by the buyer on top of the sale price) typically range from 10% to 25%, commissions (paid by the seller) can range from 0% to 25% of the selling price.

Pros

  • The auction house does most of the work
  • Professional auction houses command the most money for high-value memorabilia

Cons

  • High commissions could cut into your take
  • No guarantee of sale

Examples include:

Heritage Auctions

Heritage Auctions offers several avenues for selling autographed sports memorabilia, including direct-purchase, consignment, private sales brokering, online auctions, and live auctions. They provide no-cost estimates, but charge for appraisals and do not appear to offer authentication services. Commissions are dependent on auction type, sales price, and other variables.


SCP Auctions

You have multiple options for selling autographed sports memorabilia with SCP Auctions, including offline auctions, live and timed Internet auctions, and private sales. SCP Auctions with Sotheby’s to hold large-scale online auctions three times per year.


Lelands Auctions

Lelands Auctions offers online auctions and consignment services for autographed sports memorabilia. They offer free appraisals and live, real time online bidding. The auction house also conducts roadshows.


Julien’s Auctions

Julien’s Auctions hosts on-site and online auctions via live streaming video. Bids can be made on-location, via phone call, or online. The company also offers auction consignment services.


Grey Flannel Auctions

Grey Flannel Auctions buys memorabilia directly and offers auction consignment services. Auctions are held online and over the phone. Grey Flannel Auctions provides authentication and free “initial assessments.”


Phil Weiss Auctions

Phil Weiss Auctions claims to meet or beat others’ commission fees. The company holds online auctions and offers consignment. Fee appraisals are offered for collectibles.


Robert Edward Auctions

Robert Edward Auctions hosts live and timed online auctions and sells on consignment. The auction house’s commission ranges from 0% to 15%, depending on the item you’re selling and its value.


Huggins and Scott

Offers auction on consignment, with varying commissions depending on which auction an item sells in. All autographs sold via Huggins and Scott are authenticated by a third-party authority like JSA or PSA.


Mile High Card Co.

In addition to auction services, Mile High Card Co. will buy some items directly from the seller. Auctions are both live and online. Free verbal estimates are available for items they take in or on-site for large and valuable collections.


Goldin Auctions

Goldin Auctions holds auctions via catalog, online, and phone, in addition to hosting live auctions. Appraisals are available via phone or online contact form. Assesses commission fees.


Sotheby’s

Sotheby’s conducts auctions and private sales. Auctions are both live and online. Preliminary auction estimates are free for items that meet minimum consignment values (for example, it’s $5,000 in New York). The minimum consignment value for private sales is $100,000. Commissions are charged according to seller’s contract.


Clean Sweep Auctions

Clean Sweep Auctions buys direct and offers consignment auctions, both live and online. Appraisals are available, with a minimum cost of $100. Authentication is available for autographed items priced at $30 or more. Commission fees are 10% for items that sell for $500 or more; 15% for lots that sell for less than $500.


Infinite Auctions

Infinite Auctions presents live and online consignment auctions. The company offers free photo-matching services that can help identify the value of a given item. Commission fees vary; the standard commission is 15%, 10% if you sell two or more items, 5% if you sell five or more items, and 0% if you sell ten ore more items. All items must sell for a minimum of $1,000 to be eligible for the discounted commission rates.


Pristine Auction

Pristine Auctions hosts consignment auctions, live and online. Free appraisals are provided for autographed memorabilia. Commission fees are 15% with a minimum of $5 per lot, though lower fees are available for some items.


Steiner Auctions

Steiner Auctions presents live, timed, and online consignment auctions. The auction house offers a fair market value estimate for a $10 fee; special rates are available for large collections. Photo matching and authentication services are also available.


Hunt Auctions

In addition to hosting consignment auctions, Hunt Auctions buys some items direct. Auctions are conducted online, via phone, and in live and timed formats. Hunt Auctions offers written appraisals for $150 per hour.


RR Auction

RR Auction hosts online, time, and live auctions. The company offers authentication in-house and via third-party authenticators. In addition to consignment auctions, RR Auction pays referral fees for high-quality items.


Online auction platforms

Unlike auction houses, online auction platforms simply connect buyers and sellers; they do not represent sellers or offer appraisals and authentication services.

Pros

  • Knowledgeable buyers understand autographed memorabilia values
  • Tend to pay well
  • Convenient online sales
  • Sales moderation

Cons

  • No guarantee of sale
  • Commissions

Examples include:

Ebay

You can auction your autographed sports memorabilia on Ebay, or set a “buy it now” price to motivate quick sales. Ebay charges a 10 percent seller’s fee, but that could be offset if your item entices a bidding war.


HiBid Auctions

HiBid Auctions is a platform that connects auctioneers/auction companies with buyers and sellers. The platform offers three types of auctions: webcast live (bid live against floor bidders), Internet-only, and Internet absentee (bidding prior to a live auction).


Live Auctioneers

Live Auctioneers connects sellers and buyers through its platform, which boasts more than 4,000 auctioneers. The company operates more like Ebay than a traditional auction house, in that it does not represent the seller, act as an agent, or make any representations with respect to authenticity or value.


Sportlots

Sportlots lets you set up your own store or auction, so you can list your inventory for sale to a community of collectors and resellers. You set your own shipping fees, and there is no cost to list your items for sale on your store. Sellers pay 15 cents per auction listing, plus all PayPal fees (auction or store sales). Sellers are paid at the beginning of the month for items sold the previous month.


COMC (Check Out My Collectibles)

COMC is unique in that you create a free account, then send in your items. The company then researches your items, evaluates the condition, creates your listing, advertises on your behalf, and packs and ships any sold items. Shipping is free for sellers. You set your asking price and respond to buyer offers. View COMC’s rates here.

COMC review

 


Sports Card Direct

Create a seller account on Sports Card Direct to reach its community of buyers. Basic accounts start at $4.99 per month to list up to 100 cards per month. Premium accounts are $9.99 per month for unlimited listings, and Pro accounts are $99.99 per year. Sports Card Direct provides custom profiles, searchable listings, a listing management system, photo uploads, social media integration, and secured payments.


Online autographed sports memorabilia dealers

You can sell your autographed sports memorabilia to an online dealer. Dealers need to resell your items for a profit, so you won’t get top dollar; however, you can expect quick sales and a convenient process.

Pros

  • Guaranteed sales (typically)
  • Quick payments
  • Convenience

Cons

  • You won’t get top dollar
  • Payments are quick, but not instant
  • Potential for disputes if you misrepresent or miscommunicate what you have to sell

Examples include:

Hollywood Collectibles

Owned and operated by Rich Altman, who has represented famous athletes like Hall of Famer Bill Russell and Dwayne Wade, Hollywood Collectibles specializes in vintage autographed sports memorabilia with a focus on big names like Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, and Ted Williams, in a variety of sports including baseball, football, boxing, tennis, golf, soccer, hockey, and car racing.

Hollywood Collectibles also provides appraisal and valuation services online or directly at its Dania Beach, Florida location.


Legacy Sports Cards

Legacy Sports Cards buys sports cards made prior to 1970 as well as superstar and Hall of Famer-autographed cards, plus autographed sports memorabilia that is authenticated. Offers cash, money order, check, and PayPal payments.

Legacy Sports Cards reviews


Just Collect

You can send Just Collect a photo or visit their New Jersey offices to see if they’re interested in buying your autographed memorabilia. If you have a large or valuable collection, they’ll come to you. Appraisals and offers are free. Offers are made within 48 hours.

Just Collect reviews


Steel City Collectibles

Buys autographed sports cards and other memorabilia, with a focus on sports cards and complete sets made prior to 1970.

Steel City reviews


Sports Memorabilia

Sports Memorabilia primarily sells memorabilia, but will also buy autographed pieces. Upload photos via their online form to receive an offer.

Sports Memorabilia reviews


Richard Simon Sports

Richard Simon Sports buys only vintage memorabilia and autographs – nothing from recent or living athletes. Autographs do not need to be authenticated by a third-party service. Fill out their online form to receive an offer.

Richard Simon Sports review


Dave and Adam’s Card World

Buys sports cards, autographs, and sports memorabilia. Their website states they spent more than $30 million on collectibles last year. Fill out their online form to get an offer; if you have a particularly valuable item or large collection they might travel to you. Payments are made via cash, PayPal, or check.

Dave and Adam’s Card World reviews


Rackrs

Rackrs buys autographed memorabilia and sports cards, with a focus on the San Antonio Spurs, Houston Rockets, Dallas Mavericks, Houston Astros, and Texas Rangers; however, they’ll consider any autographed sports memorabilia. Fill out their online form to receive an email offer. If you have a prized item, they will travel to you.


Ultimate Sports Cards and Memorabilia

Owned by Jeremy Brown, who is often featured as a sports memorabilia expert on the TV show Pawn Stars, Ultimate Sports Cards and Memorabilia must physically examine items before making an offer. Start the process by filling out their online contact form.

Ultimate Sports Cards and Memorabilia reviews


Dugout Dreams

Buys autographed sports memorabilia including rookie cards (graded or ungraded), programs, tickets, photos, uniforms, pre-1979 sports cards, baseballs, bats, jerseys, and any Hall of Fame-themed items, mini-helmets, and more. Fill out the online form to receive an offer.

Dugout Dreams reviews


The Cardboard Connection

The Cardboard Connection facilitates sales of sports cards and autographed memorabilia. They specialize in vintage and moderate to high-dollar modern cards. Fill out the contact form, and their buying partners will contact you within one to two business days to provide a free appraisal.


Cactus League Sports

Buys vintage sports cards, autographs, game used equipment, and sports memorabilia. Their website states that they’re most interested in N Cards, T cards, E Cards, Goudey Gum, Play Ball, Topps, Bowman, Fleer, and Post Cereal cards. Call their Scottsdale, Arizona store to receive an offer.

Cactus League Sports reviews


Anything Goes

Anything Goes buys sports memorabilia, including sports cards, autographed items, signed baseballs (with certifications), mini helmets, and Ranger and Cowboy items. Start the process by contacting them via phone, email, or online form.

Anything Goes reviews


Collectibles Hub

Located in North Dallas, Collectibles Hub primarily buys sports card collections and memorabilia in the Dallas area; however, they’re interested in collections from anywhere. Call or fill out the appraisal form to get the process started.


Imperial Sports

Imperial Sports buys autographed sports memorabilia direct or via auction. They’re interested in vintage baseball signatures ranging from the 19th to the mid-20th century, turn-of-the-century photographs, team composites and solo portraits, and cabinet cards. Fill out the online form to receive an offer.


Dean’s Cards

Dean’s Cards purchases vintage baseball card collections dated pre-1975, as well as complete sets dated between 1976 and 1985. Complete the online form, and they’ll contact you within one business day with detailed information on how to sell your cards to them and how much they pay. Payments are made via check.

Dean’s Cards reviews


BBC Emporium

Buys baseball, basketball, and football card collections dated pre-1970. Contact them and send a list of your items, along with any photos, to receive a free quote within one to three days. If you have a large or valuable collection, they will travel to you. Payment is submitted via check, money order, or PayPal. BBC Emporium will reimburse you for any shipping fees.


California Sports Cards

California Sports Cards buys autographed cards and sports memorabilia, including game-used bats, jerseys, autographed balls, photos, and more. All autographed items must be authenticated by a major third-party authenticator. Call or email for additional information.

California Sports Cards review


707 Sportscards

Primarily interested in pre-1970 baseball cards, in all conditions (poor to mint), both graded and ungraded. 707 Sports buys collections both large and small, sets, singles, and commons. They also offer consignment services, either for retail sale or at auction. The company travels to large shows nationwide to buy, sell, and trade vintage cards. Call or email to learn more.


Sports memorabilia forums

Online forums dedicated to autographs and sports memorabilia often feature buy/sell threads you can use to sell your items. You can also consult these forums for advice, help identifying what you have to sell, and setting a price.

Keep in mind most forums have no moderation; if you decide to sell your memorabilia to another forum member, be sure to fully vet them and protect yourself against scams.

Pros

  • You can get more money by selling directly to buyers
  • Most do no charge commissions
  • Exposure to a passionate audience

Cons

  • No moderation, so there is potential for scams and disputes
  • No guarantee of sale (or sales could take a long time)

Examples include:


Local dealers

Local card shops and sports memorabilia dealers often buy autographed sports memorabilia. Just like their online counterparts, they need to resell for a profit – so you won’t get top dollar, but you will get an instant cash (or store credit) sale.

Local dealers will also sell on consignment, which means they’ll display your item in-store (and sometimes online), then take a commission when it sells.

Many local dealers also have online platforms for remote buying and selling. For example, Ultimate Sports Cards and Memorabilia buys online and at its brick-and-mortar location in Las Vegas; and Hollywood Collectibles deals both online and at its Dania Beach, Florida location.

Search Google for local options, or stroll through nearby flea markets to find dealers. You might want to check local pawn shops. You can also check out this list of PSA Authorized Dealers.

Pros

  • Fastest sales
  • Local convenience

Cons

  • Other options pay more
  • You need to know the value of your items before you agree to selling to avoid a low offer
  • You might need to negotiate to get a fair price

Local classifieds

Local classifieds are perhaps less popular for selling autographed sports memorabilia, but they do present another option. Local buyers offer instant cash payments, but the market is limited so you might not be able to find a buyer. Local classifieds aren’t moderated, either, so you need to be careful.

Pros

  • Quick payments
  • No fees

Cons

  • No guarantee of sale
  • No moderation
  • Potential for hassles like no-shows and scams

Examples include:

Facebook Marketplace

If there are local buyers, you might be able to reach them via Facebook marketplace. There are no fees, but there is also no moderation. You can also reach a wider audience via Facebook groups like Sports Cards and Memorabilia Buy/Sell/Trade and Sports Memorabilia Buy/Sell/Trade.


Craigslist

Though immensely popular, Craigslist isn’t well-known for autographed sports memorabilia. Still, you might find a local buyer.


OfferUp

OfferUp could be described as a more-refined Craigslist, complete with a mobile app and security features like anonymous contact information, a buyer rating system, and ID verification.


LetGo

Like OfferUp, LetGo allows you to vet buyers before you sell. It’s free to post, but you can pay for a featured listing.


Sports memorabilia events, conventions. trade shows, and flea markets

Sports memorabilia events, trade shows, and flea markets provide excellent selling opportunities, since they’re often attended by passionate and knowledgeable buyers. Search Google for local and regional events.

Pros

  • Access to a large pool of enthusiastic buyers
  • Potential for quick cash sales
  • Fun, if you enjoy the environment

Cons

  • No guarantee of sale
  • Potential travel expenses and lots of time involved
  • You need to know the value of your item to avoid being duped

The National Sports Collectors Convention is perhaps the best-known event; you can find others listed on PSA’s website and The Cardboard Connection.


Autographed sports memorabilia selling tips

Use these tips to get the most out of your selling experience.

1. Know what you have – and get it graded and authenticated

Take the time to research the value of your autographed sports memorabilia. It’s the only way to ensure you’re getting a fair price. Consider having your item graded to set its condition. And, unless your item has ironclad provenance, get it authenticated – especially if it’s valuable. A Letter of Authenticity will satisfy the most serious of high-bidders. Companies like Beckett, PSA, and Sportscard Guaranty provide grading services. PSA and JSA are recognized as trusted authenticators.

2. Ask for help

If you can’t identify your memorabilia, ask for help. You can consult community advice via the forums listed in this article; for expert advice, get an appraisal from an expert like Leila Dunbar.

3. Set your priorities

Decide what you want out of your selling experience. If you want the highest price, a traditional auction house might be your best bet. If you want a quick and convenient sale you can complete from home, online dealers are the way to go. If you need fast cash today, local dealers are your best options.

Find The Value of Your iPhone

iPhone X iPhone 8 Plus iPhone 8
iPhone 7 Plus iPhone 7 All iPhones

4. Stay safe

Vet buyers before completing any sale. Never send your valuable memorabilia through the mail without receiving payment first, or at least an escrow deposit. If you’re selling to a private buyer offline, take a friend along and meet in a well-lit, busy public place.

5. Create a winning listing

Make your autographed sports memorabilia command attention with these tips:

  • Write a full, detailed description that includes the condition of your memorabilia, the autograph, the year it was autographed, anything significant about the item (such as game use), information about the person who signed it, the history and provenance of the item, and whether it has been authenticated (and who provided the authentication)
  • Include large, full-color photos featuring multiple angles, as well as any notable features and flaws
  • Your description should be accurate and fair, complete with the item’s graded condition (and who graded it), to avoid potential disputes
  • Unless set by the platform, be sure to include sale terms like shipping fees, taxes, and other policies. Eliminate any surprises that could give would-be buyers cold feet
  • Set a fair price. Your research will help you identify value, then you can price accordingly. If you set the price at market value, you stand a good chance of selling to collectors. If you want a quick sale, you can set your price below market value
  • Always respond to questions as soon as possible to avoid losing potential sales

The world of autographed sports memorabilia is enormous, but you can use the advice and resources in this article to get the most money and the most enjoyable selling experience when you sell your autographed sports memorabilia.

Previous:
Next:

X

Ready for a new phone? Flipsy helps you get the most cash for your old one.