The Complete Guide to How Much Your Diamonds Are Worth (and Where to Sell Them)
Here’s how to find the value of your diamonds, where to sell them, and how to avoid scams in this definitive diamond selling guide
Thinking about selling your diamonds? Whether you’re ready to part with a diamond you’ve worn for years, want to sell an heirloom diamond passed down through generations, or simply found a diamond in an old drawer, our guide will show you how to find out how much your diamonds are worth and where to sell diamonds for the most money.
- How much are diamonds worth?
- What makes diamonds valuable?
- How to find the value of your diamonds
- Where to sell diamonds
- Diamond selling tips
How much are diamonds worth?
Most diamond values range between a few hundred dollars to a few thousand dollars, according to Neil Beaty, a professional appraiser at American Gem Registry.
“It’s a complicated topic and mostly it’s not about gemology. It’s about marketing,” says Beaty.
Mike Fried, CEO of The Diamond Pro – a free service that educates buyers and helps them find quality diamonds – says $5,000 is the average price tag his readers pay for diamonds.
“That is generally the budget for a nice one carat diamond,” he says.
What about the most valuable diamonds in the world? The record belongs to the “Pink Star,” a 59.6 carat diamond that sold at an April 2017 Sotheby’s Hong Kong auction for $71.2 Million USD. That same diamond had originally been auctioned for $83 million, but the buyer failed to pay.
The previous record sale was $57.6 million USD, which was commanded by the “Oppenheimer Blue” diamond at a May 2016 auction.
Image source: Sotheby’s
These figures don’t even touch the values of famous diamonds:
The Cullinan: A whopping 3,106.75 carats in its rough state when found in 1905, this diamond has since been cut into nine distinctive stones (plus an additional 96 minor stones and 9 polished fragments) and is now in possession of the British crown. Collectively, the nine major diamonds are estimated to be worth more than $2 billion. The largest stone, the Cullinan I (also known as the “Great Star of Africa”), is 530.2 carats and estimated to be worth as much as $400 million.
Koh-I-Noor: This 105.6 carat diamond, known as the “Mountain of Light,” was mined in the 1300s and carries an estimated value of more than $1 billion. Some believe the Koh-I-Noor is a legendary diamond that originally surfaced in Sanskrit writings dating back more than 5,000 years.
Image source: The Smithsonian
These diamonds might be priceless, but chances are your diamonds are not.
As Beaty puts it: “High-end diamonds are a game for museums and collectors, and it’s a different sort of marketplace from us regular humans. The market to museums and oil zillionaires has nothing to do with the topic at hand.”
What makes diamonds valuable?
Diamond values are dictated by the four C’s:
Let’s break down each.
Diamond colors are graded from D to Z, with D being the best: a colorless diamond. Check out the Gemological Institute of America’s Diamond Color page for an interactive tool that illustrates the differences between diamond colors by grade.
Though a colorless diamond will typically be more valuable than one that has a golden tint, pink and blue diamonds can be more valuable than colorless diamonds.
Clarity is a grade ascribed according to the number, size, shape, and location of a diamond’s inclusions (internal marks) and blemishes (external marks) that can be observed at 10x magnification.
A diamond could be given one of 11 clarity grades, from six different categories:
- Flawless (FL)
- Internally Flawless (IF)
- Very, Very Slightly Included (VVS1, VVS2)
- Very Slightly Included (VS1, VS2)
- Slightly Included (SI1, SI2)
- Included (I1, I2, I3)
You can compare different clarity grades with GIA’s interactive tool.
The cut of a diamond is less about its shape than it is the way the facets direct light. According to the GIA website, the proportions of those facets inform experts about a diamond’s:
- Brightness (Reflected white light)
- Fire (Scattering of white light into all the colors of the spectrum)
- Scintillation (Sparkle)
Those attributes are then used to grade diamond cuts according to the GIA scale:
- Very Good
Perhaps the best-known diamond descriptor, a carat weighs 200 milligrams. Carat weight plays a key role in diamond values; as carats increase, so do values since larger diamonds are rarer.
Check out the GIA’s diamond carat visualization to better understand the difference between, say, a half-carat diamond and a five-carat diamond.
Keep in mind a diamond’s value is not dictated by any one factor, but by how each of these four C’s interact with one another to deliver a single, cohesive visual.
Other things that can impact diamond values include:
- Pavilion depth percentage
- Accompanying valuables, such as when a diamond is set in a gold ring
- Historical value
- Enhancements or repairs, which generally make diamonds less valuable
For more information, check out GIA’s guide to diamond quality.
How to find the value of your diamonds
So far, we know most diamonds are worth anywhere from a few hundred dollars to a few thousand dollars; and we know diamond values are dictated by the four C’s.
But the real question is: How much are YOUR diamonds worth?
The experts we interviewed recommended two different approaches to determining diamond values:
|1. Ask a qualified appraiser|
Beaty recommends seeking an appraiser from the following organizations:
He adds you’re better off choosing an appraiser over a jeweler.
“There’s a difference. Use an appraiser. Jewelers, in general, don’t know much; although some do both. It’s like evaluating problems with your car by talking to a salesperson at the showroom. They might know, but you’re a lot better off talking to a mechanic,” he says. “Pay attention to credentials. Appraising is a totally unregulated business and charlatans abound. Special note, for example: GIA’s Graduate Gemologist diploma is not an appraisal credential. Also be aware of the conflict of interest if your ‘appraiser’ is trying to buy it from you. Your interests are not aligned with theirs.”
Beaty said appraisal fees vary from appraiser to appraiser and depend on the market as well as depth of information offered. In the Denver market, where he operates, $100 to $150 is a typical starting fee.
|2. Do it yourself|
Fried recommends the do-it-yourself method, but says you should first have your diamonds certified.
“It is imperative that a diamond has legitimate certification,” he says. “Once it has a legitimate certification, you are easily able to compare apples to apples. Just find a comparable diamond on a website like Blue Nile and see if the price is fair.”
AGS services businesses exclusively, but individuals can find a local AGS member to have their diamonds graded and certified.
Once your diamonds have been certified, you can check the popular marketplace Blue Nile to find diamonds that feature the same color, clarity, cut, and carat to get a good estimate for how much your diamonds are worth.
Fried warns readers to be wary of conflicts of interest.
“Jewelers have a vested interest in knocking the ring you bring in to have appraised, looking for a future customer,” he says. “Theoretically that isn’t a problem for appraisers, but who’s to say they don’t have a vested interest either? They can easily trash a ring you bring in and say you are better off buying a diamond from a different store they coincidentally get a kick back from? There is no system in place to stop that.”
What if you just want to know if your diamonds are real?
“Ask a competent gemologist,” says Beaty. “It’s not all that difficult and usually you can get a stone ID for free. There are too many potential traps with do-it-yourself stone ID’s and it’s just not necessary given that it’s a free service in most places. Be aware that grading is not the same thing and usually isn’t free. Actually, it’s worse than that. ‘Free’ grading will normally end up getting paid for in other ways, like when they give you a bid. Free opinions are often worth less than they cost.”
Where to sell your diamonds
Beaty says there are three general paths to selling diamonds:
- Direct retail sale
- Selling to dealers
- Selling via dealer consignment
Let’s break each one down.
“What unifies these is that you’re doing all the work, you’re taking all the risks, and you get all the money,” says Beaty. “It has a lot to do with your selling skills, what you think of your relatives, and other non-gemological properties. If you’re good at it, this is where the most money is. If you’re bad at it, this is also where you’re likely to get suckered or worse.”
Selling to dealers
In this scenario, you sell your diamonds directly to dealers. You’ll be selling at a discount, since dealers need to make a profit on resale. Dealers include jewelers, pawn shops, and professional diamond buyers.
“They give you money and you go away. It’s their problem now,” says Beaty. “This takes the least skill, the least investment, the least time, and produces the least money.”
Selling via dealer consignment
Under the consignment model, you take your diamond to a dealer, who puts it on display in their store. You get paid when it sells.
“The difference between this and the above is when you get paid: you don’t get paid until they do,” says Beaty. “That means you have to care if they are displaying things properly, if they’re negotiating well on your behalf, if they’re still in business, etc. That is to say, it’s still your problem. Some jewelers do this, auction houses do it, some websites do it. A lot of appraisers offer brokerage-type services.”
Where to sell diamonds online
There are hundreds of websites that either directly purchase diamonds or help you connect with buyers. Here are some of the most popular:
Submit your GIA report and receive an offer within one business day. If you accept, Abe Mor will send you a free shipping kit that’s insured for the value of your diamond. Checks are sent via priority mail within one business day; wire transfers are completed within two to four business days. If you do not have a GIA report, you can send your diamond to Abe Mor to receive an offer.
Worthy grades your diamonds, diamond rings, or other diamond jewelry using a partner like GIA, then puts it up for auction. Before your diamond goes to auction, you will agree to a minimum bid. If your diamond doesn’t sell at auction within seven days, Worthy will buy it at the minimum bid price. If you find a better offer from a local jeweler, they’ll also pay you $100.
Worthy offers free insured shipping and pays via PayPal within two business days after you approve the sale. Fees are only paid once your diamond sells, and start at $150 for diamonds worth up to $750.
Mail your diamonds via FedEx overnight service, and WP Diamonds will evaluate them and make an offer. Shipments are insured for up to $200,000 (more expensive items are shipped via Brinks), and your package is opened on video to ensure there are no discrepancies. If you accept the offer, you will be issued payment the same day via check or wire transfer.
Fill out Speedy Diamond’s online form and the company will make an offer. If you accept, Speedy Diamond will give you a FedEx shipping label that insures the package in the amount of your offer (more expensive items are sent via Brinks). Once your diamond is received and inspected, Speedy Diamond will submit payment within five hours via wire transfer. You can also opt to be paid by check or PayPal.
If you’re worried about friends, family, or co-workers noticing your diamond is missing from your ring, Speedy Diamond will seat a cubic zirconia in it and ship it back to you at no charge.
Fill out an online form and upload a picture to receive an initial estimate from Luxury Buyers. If you like the estimate, they’ll issue you a prepaid and insured FedEx overnight shipping label. You’ll receive a final offer once your diamonds are inspected (within 48 hours of receipt). If you accept, you’ll be paid via wire transfer or check.
Sell Your Gold
Request a free appraisal kit, which includes a prepaid and insured FedEx shipping label, then ship your diamonds to Sell Your Gold. You can optionally choose an online shipping kit, which lets you print your own label and use your own packaging in return for a 5% bonus. Sell Your Gold will evaluate your diamonds and submit an offer; if you accept, you will be paid via your choice of direct deposit, check, or PayPal. Sell Your Gold offers a price match guarantee.
Diamond Buyers International
Diamond Buyers International claims to eliminate middlemen and pay more for your diamonds. Use the online appraisal calculator to get an instant estimate. If you like it, you can request a free FedEx shipping kit insured for up to $5,000 (alternatively, you can print your shipping label online). Once your diamonds are received and inspected, Diamond Buyers International will send payment via check, PayPal, or direct deposit.
Submit your GIA grading report or send your diamonds securely to Mondiamo for evaluation. Shipping is free and insured via FedEx. If you submit a GIA report, Mondiamo will make an offer with a guaranteed cash range. If you need to have your diamonds inspected, they’ll make an offer after they receive your diamonds. Once your diamonds are inspected, Mondiamo will make a final offer. Accept and you will be paid via check or bank wire within one to two business days. If you sell your jewelry via Mondiamo, you can receive a $150 credit toward the purchase of jewelry on Blue Nile.
I Do Now I Don’t
There are two ways to sell diamonds on IDNID: sell directly to them, or sell to end users via the marketplace.
If you sell directly to IDNID, a representative will call you with an estimate. If the price is agreeable, you’ll be issued a free insured shipping label. Once IDNID receives your diamonds, you’ll be given a final offer. Accept, and payment will be issued via check.
If you sell via IDNID’s marketplace, you’ll start by registering a free account and listing your diamonds for sale. You can keep your diamonds until they sell or ship them to IDNID to hold in escrow. If your diamonds sell, IDNID will collect payment from the buyer and place it in escrow. They’ll then authenticate your diamonds, ship them to the buyer, and submit payment via check. IDNID charges a 15% commission on all diamonds sold.
In addition to dedicated diamond buyers, you can sell your diamonds online via eBay. Many buyers will require GIA certification before they’ll pay (GIA will even microscopically laser etch your grading on the diamond to prove its certification). There is no guarantee of sale, and as with any peer-to-peer selling, there is always a chance of scams. However, eBay does have a seller protection policy.
Sell your diamonds at a pre-set buy-it-now price or see if you can get higher bids via auction. eBay takes a 10% fee from all completed sales, and payouts are submitted via PayPal.
Where to sell your diamonds locally
Jewelers, pawn shops, professional diamond buyers and brokers, and Craigslist are all options for selling your diamonds locally. You might also consider selling your diamonds via Facebook Marketplace. Be sure to check out our diamond selling tips below before you sell.
Resources for finding local diamond buyers include:
If you can’t find a local buyer via these links, try a Google search for jewelers, pawn shops, and diamond dealers, brokers, and appraisers in your area.
Diamond selling tips
Use these five tips to get the most out of your diamond-selling experience.
1. Understand what you have
When you know what you have, you can compare apples-to-apples and ensure you’re getting a fair price for your diamonds. Beaty recommends having your diamonds graded by a lab, evaluated by an appraiser, or both.
As Fried puts it: “I’m constantly reminded of radio ads for an old-school men’s clothing company, Syms – ‘an educated consumer is our best customer.’”
2. Manage your expectations
Compare retail values for diamonds that are similar to what you have to set realistic expectations for value. Unless you’re selling directly to an end user, understand that most buyers need to resell your diamond for a profit – which means you won’t get full retail value.
“When a jeweler or appraiser isn’t actually offering to buy your diamond, they will extol on the virtues of the diamond ad-infinitum. The second they need to put cash on the table, every problem and flaw will be highlighted,” says Fried. “Fluorescence, cut, clouds, and slow-moving markets are all excuses to undermine the value of a diamond.”
Beaty adds: “People tend to overvalue their stuff. That’s OK, you can ask whatever you want, but it doesn’t usually result in sales. You can waste a lot of time trying to find someone who has been drinking the same Kool-Aid that you have.”
3. Don’t believe everything you’ve heard
“Sellers have a habit of inflating grades and appraisal values,” says Beaty. “In particular, replacement value is not the same as resale value. It’s like valuing your car by pointing out that the dealers are currently asking $30,000 for that model. Bully for them. That doesn’t mean you can get that, or for that matter, even that they can.”
4. Get multiple offers
Unless you know exactly what your diamonds are worth and get an amazing offer for them, it’s a good idea to seek multiple offers. This is the best way to get the most money for your diamonds. In the case of online diamond buyers, quotes are free and it can literally pay to compare.
5. Read the fine print
Never sign a contract or agree to sell your diamonds without completely understanding the deal, and that includes reading the fine print. Always understand who pays for shipping, your obligations as a seller, and any commissions and selling fees. Make sure your diamonds will be safe and secure throughout the entire selling process. Understand when and how you will be paid. Always have your shipments insured.
Selling diamonds can be complicated and confusing, even overwhelming, for first-time sellers. Use the tips and resources in this article to your advantage so you can sell your diamonds for the best price.
Next: $300 trade-in credit for a $50 phone? Is Verizon’s trade-in offer a good deal?