arrow-down
Home » Selling Guides » Books and Magazines

Your Old Magazine Could Be Worth $50,000 – Or More. Here’s How to Sell It

sell old magazines

Are your old magazines worth anything? Find out with the definitive guide to selling magazines

Have you kept your favorite issue of Sports Illustrated for decades? Stumbled upon a box of old National Geographic editions in Grandma’s attic? Found your dad’s long-lost stash of Playboy?

Wonder if those old magazines are worth anything?

Here, Flipsy.com shows you what makes magazines valuable, how to determine their values, and where to sell them.

Contents

Looking to sell your phone? Get top-dollar offers from Trust Verified stores here:

The most valuable magazines in the world

In 2007, a copy of Beeton’s Christmas Annual 1887 sold at a Sotheby’s auction for $156,000. To-date, that stands as the highest price ever paid for a magazine – but that doesn’t make it the most valuable magazine in the world. In 2010, another copy of that same issue fetched a $445,000 bid, but the bid didn’t meet the reserve and the sale did not take place.

Magazine pricing service Nostomania pegs Playboy as publishing the three most valuable magazine issues in the world. If you happen to have the first edition of Playboy (V1 #1) featuring Marilyn Monroe in perfect mint condition, it’s worth as much as $635,000.

Before you start building your mansion, know that it’s highly unlikely you have a Playboy – or any magazine – in mint condition. In fact, Nostomania states it’s unaware of any magazine issue that has ever been graded at a perfect mint 10.0 condition. The site uses a baseline of 9.4 (near mint) to create its list of the 100 most valuable magazines, and even then states that many of the magazines on the list do not exist in that high of a grade.

More realistically, any magazines you have are likely to grade somewhere between 2.0 (good) and 6.0 (fine), with the average magazine grading around 4.0 (very good) and 5.0 (very good/fine).

That doesn’t mean they can’t be valuable: that Marilyn Monroe Playboy is still worth up to $2,100 in good condition (4.0) and $4,500 in fine (6.0) condition. We’ll go into more detail about how condition affects value below.

First Playboy Magazine

Source: Live Auction Group

What makes a magazine valuable?

Simply put, a magazine’s value is determined by how much someone will pay for it. Unlike many fields, magazines aren’t typically purchased to add to a “magazine collection,” but as secondary pieces for a primary collection.

For example, Beeton’s Christmas Annual 1887 isn’t prized because it’s a Christmas edition of Beeton’s, but because it’s the first time Sherlock Holmes appeared on a printed page (Arthur Conan Doyle’s “A Study of Scarlet”). Thus, this issue is valuable to people who collect Sherlock Holmes.

“Look for magazines that have content that is collected in other fields,” says appraiser John Henley. “Sherlock Holmes book collectors desire copies of the Strand Magazine that ran the stories before they were published as books. Some science fiction collectors want pulp magazines or even science fiction digest magazines with first appearances by Philip K. Dick or Frank Herbert. You have to explore the markets for all kinds of collectibles to understand what magazines will likely fetch higher amounts of money.”

Beeton's Christmas Annual 1887

Source: Wikimedia Commons

Characteristics that contribute to magazine value include:

  • First literary appearances
  • Edition (first editions can be valuable)
  • Date
  • Photographs
  • Popular culture
  • Artistic merit
  • Age
  • Current trends
  • Historic events
  • Cover art
  • Advertisements
  • Featured celebrities and sports stars
  • Misprints and mistakes
  • Rarity
  • Demand
  • Condition
  • Certification status (f the magazine has been certified by a qualified appraiser)
  • Signatures and inscriptions
  • Niche/collectible interest
  • Complete collections

Special covers and inserts can also enhance magazine value, according to Cole Ferry, owner and senior appraiser of W.C Ferry and Associates.

“The first two issues of Sports Illustrated are prized because of color and black-and-white baseball cards that were included in the issues,” he says. “Likewise, on November 29, 1963, Life originally published a cover of quarterback Roger Staubach but recalled the seven-million-issue run to replace the cover with news of Kennedy’s assassination. Today, the issue – when found – may retail for as much as $1,800.”

Roger Staubach Life Magazine cover 1963

Source: Farther Off the Wall with Tom Offarth (InsideCoCal.com)

Magazine artwork can significantly increase a given issue’s value. For example, Norman Rockwell’s Saturday Evening Post covers and Winslow Homer’s Harper’s Weekly illustrations are the reasons those publications have interest and value, says Cole. Henley adds that magazines featuring photographs by Minor White can likewise be valuable.

Have a phone to sell? Trust verified stores compete to offer 30% more than carrier trade-in programs. Find out how much yours is worth.

iPhone Samsung Sony
ZTE HTC More Androids

What about those boxes of National Geographic?

“Even low-value magazines such as National Geographic – sorry to all those who have stacks of them – have back cover Coca-Cola ads that are prized, especially those with Santa Claus,” Cole says.

When it comes to magazines, there are no rules for what makes a given issue valuable to one person and not another. One person might want a National Geographic issue because it features a destination they once visited, while another might be interested in a Rolling Stones issue because it features the Beatles on the cover. Yet another person might want a given magazine because it was published on their birthday or wedding day.

“A potential buyer might find an article or an image that might compel them to purchase the magazine,” says Dale Sorenson, of Dale A. Sorenson Appraisals. “Someone wants the magazine for some reason for which they might pay more than the original list price.”

“This is a very complex issue, but as a rule, magazine collecting is a second-tier form of collecting to fill out a larger collection of first-tier items,” explains Henley. “Like Sherlock Holmes collectors first getting their book collection, then filling out their magazine collection, then getting their Sherlock Holmes wardrobe collection, and so on.”

National Geographic Moon Landing

Source: National Geographic

How to tell how much your magazines are worth

Despite so many variables, you have several options for determining magazine values. Start by understanding what, exactly, you have.

Know what you have

Begin by listing everything you know about your magazine, including:

  • Date, edition, and volume
  • Notable articles or writers
  • Featured celebrities or sports stars
  • Cover art, interior artwork, and photography
  • Articles and content
  • Notable advertisements

Next, determine the condition of your magazines. The grades are listed below, but check out Nostomania’s guide to magazine conditions for full details and examples.

GRADECONDITIONDESCRIPTION
 
10.0Gem MintAbsolutely perfect condition, as though it was never handled
 
9.9MintNearly perfect. Subtle flaws only. Sharp corners. No creasing, tearing, or browning
 
9.8Near Mint/MintA few very minor flaws. Sharp corners. No creasing, tearing, or browning
 
9.6Near Mint+Minor imperfections. Appears unread. No creasing or tearing. Pages could be slightly off-white
 
9.4Near MintMinor imperfections.Appears as though it was read once or twice. No creasing or tearing, except very minor bindery tears
 
9.2Near Mint–Minor imperfections. Appears as though it was read a few times. Corners may have minor blunting. A single minor crease is allowed
 
9.0Very Fine/Near MintAppears carefully handled. Limited number of flaws. Corners may show minor wear. Cover may have minor wear
 
8.5Very Fine+Similar to 9.0, but might have lightly tanned pages and a small tear
 
8.0Very FineMinor handling wear. Minor cover soiling. Small piece may be missing. Small cover crease allowed
 
7.5Very Fine–Minor handling wear. Slightly discolored pages. Limited number of bindery/printing flaws. Small cover crease and minor soiling
 
7.0Fine/Very FineAbove average with minor wear. Blunted corners. Slightly faded cover, minor creases, soiling, and wear
 
6.5Fine+Above average with minor wear. Tanned pages. Small staple tears and discoloration
 
6.0FineAbove average with minor wear. Minor to moderate cover creases. Loose centerfold
 
5.5FineAbove average with minor wear. Appears to have been read several times. Spine may have small split with color breaks. Small piece may be missing
 
5.0Very Good/FineAverage used copy. Appears to have been ready many times. Moderate spine roll or split. Missing corner triangle. Cover wear
 
4.5Very Good+Average used copy with significant wear. Cover may have subscription crease. Cover soiling. Page discoloration. Minor tears
 
4.0Very GoodSimilar to 4.5, but centerfold may be loose and detached at one staple
 
3.5Very Good–Additional tearing, creasing, and color breaks allowed. Centerfold may be detached. Slightly rounded corners
 
3.0Good/Very GoodSignificant wear, yet still complete. Rounded corners. Additional tearing, creasing, and color breaks
 
2.5Good+Significant wear, yet still complete. Small corner or edge piece may be missing
 
2.0GoodSignificant wear, yet still complete. Little to no reflectivity left on cover. Cover and centerfold may be detached
 
1.8Good–Very rough, yet still complete
 
1.5Fair/GoodVery rough, appears as though it wasn’t cared for, yet still complete
 
1.0FairVery heavy wear, yet still includes a cover
 
0.5PoorVery heavy wear, missing cover
 
0.3IncompletePortions of the magazine are missing



You might note that condition nomenclature remains fairly positive, even at the lower end of the grading scale.

“Since magazines are ephemeral in nature – that is, they were never meant to be saved – they are graded on a much more forgiving scale than fine art,” explains Ferry. “The highest designation of condition given is usually fine. Mint or unread copies, unless acquired directly from the publisher, are rarely found. Torn covers, loose bindings, inept tape repairs, and missing pages are all factors in designations that may run from good to fair to poor.”

Have a phone to sell? Trust verified stores compete to offer 30% more than carrier trade-in programs. Find out how much yours is worth.

iPhone Samsung Sony
ZTE HTC More Androids

That is to say, don’t be discouraged just because your magazines aren’t in mint condition. Though condition does significantly impact value, even some incomplete issues can be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars.

Still, it’s smart to temper your expectations.

“It is a cold, hard fact that most magazines are of very modest value, often between $5 and $20,” says Ferry.

It can take years for an appraiser to learn how to properly grade magazines, which is why issues certified by appraisers or a service such as CGC Magazines are more valuable than those that are not certified.

CGC charges anywhere from $28 to $77 per graded magazine, though those price tiers have limits to how much your magazine can be worth to qualify. PastPaper.com also offers magazine grading services, though no price is listed.

Keep in mind that grading and appraising are two different services. Grading simply tells you what condition your magazine is in; a seasoned appraiser can tell you how much it’s worth.

Magazine grading versus appraisal

Auction houses, bookstores, and antique stores might also be able to assist with assessing the condition of your magazines.

How to determine how much your magazine is worth

Once you know what magazine you have and its condition, you can use several tools to determine how much it’s worth.

Nostomania

One of the most comprehensive online resources for magazine values, Nostomania gives magazine values based on real-world sales and its own algorithm. Pricing is as low as $2.99 per month, though it comes with a free trial. Its database offers pricing for 195 different magazines, so it’s worth giving the free trial a go to see if they offer values for your magazine.

Antique Trader’s Vintage Magazines

An exceptional guide to magazine values as well as extensive information on what makes magazines valuable, including “sleepers” that might surprise. You can find the paperback for less than $10, or buy an ebook copy for around $20. The book was published in 2005, so the values aren’t necessarily up-to-date, but you can get a good idea for what your magazines might be worth and the background information is pure gold for collectors and sellers.

Ebay

What better way to see how much money you can get for your magazine than to see how much similar copies have recently sold for? Search for your magazine on Ebay, then check the left sidebar box to show only sold listings. Now, you can scroll through the results to see how much your issue has recently sold for. Pay attention to conditions!

WorthPoint Worthopedia

WorthPoint’s Worthopedia draws data from more than 350 sources – including Ebay – to help you value your old magazines. The service costs $19.99 per month, but offers a 7-day free trial – perfect if you have just a few magazines to research.

VintageMagazines.com

A good resource for hard-to-find magazines. It doesn’t list how much magazines have recently sold for, but it does have its own store with clearly-labeled magazine prices. You can use those prices as a guideline for how much your magazines are worth.

Past Paper

Though its website is dated, Past Paper boasts an enormous number of magazine listings. You can browse for your magazine to see how much it’s listed for, and use that as a guide to set your own pricing.

Back Issues

Browse or search for your magazine, and Back Issues will take you to its online store where you can view pricing. Again, use it as a guide to set your own price.

2Neat Magazines

2Neat specializes in Life magazines; browse or search for your issue to see how much they’re selling it for. You can also check out its second site for issues of LOOK, Saturday Evening Post, and Liberty.

Have it appraised

More valuable magazines often require the help of an appraiser, who might charge $250 per hour or more, with a total fee ranging from $2,500 to $7,500 depending on the amount of research and travel required.

Having your magazines appraised will give you the best idea of their values. However, appraisals can be expensive and are best-reserved for magazines you know are valuable. Your best bet is to first research your magazine online, and if it appears to be very valuable you can enlist the services of an appraiser.

“Formal, written appraisals of large collections may be costly, but essential for proper insurance coverage, donations to a nonprofit institution, or for real estate purposes,” says Ferry. He adds that qualified appraisers must be compliant with Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) and certify the written report accordingly. You can likely get an estimate of total costs to determine whether a full appraisal is worth the investment.

You can find quality appraisers through the American Society of Appraisers, the Appraisers Association of America, the Ephemera Society of America, or the International Society of Appraisers; or, consult with one of the experts who contributed to this article:

Saturday Evening Post Norman Rockwell Santa Claus cover

Source: Pinterest

Where to sell old magazines

Once you know how much your magazine is worth, you have a variety of selling options.

Ebay

The online auction site is a popular place to sell magazines for a variety of reasons. First, you’re typically selling directly to collectors, so you’re able to get a good price (whereas dealers must buy at a lower price so they can profit from markups). Second, the auction format can drive up prices for in-demand issues and collections – even above retail market value, which can help offset the cost of Ebay’s seller fees (10% with a maximum of $750).

Etsy

Etsy might not be the first site that comes to mind when you think about selling magazines, but the service boasts a robust community of magazine buyers and sellers – particularly for vintage issues. Again, you’re selling directly to collectors, but without an auction format. Fees are $0.20 per listing, plus 6.75% in transaction and payment processing fees.

Abe Books

Though primarily an online bookstore, Abe Books has a large “magazines and periodicals” category. You can list your magazines for sale on their store for $25 per month (plus an 8% commission fee and 3.5% to 5.5% payment processing fee).

Other websites

Several websites buy old magazines, each with its own policies and interests. When you deal directly with websites, you don’t have to wait to see if your listing will sell via online stores or auction sites. However, websites are dealers, so you won’t get top dollar for your magazines. Search for websites that buy and sell magazines by title or that deal in specific collectible disciplines. Four websites that buy magazines directly from sellers are:

Auction Houses

Contact auction houses to see if your magazines would be a good fit for an upcoming auction. Auction houses are perhaps best-suited for high-value issues. Auction houses can help you command higher prices for your magazines, but they’ll also take a hefty fee – likely around 25% of the sold price. Find one by checking out Artnet’s comprehensive list of auction houses.

Flea markets and antique shows

Collectors routinely browse flea markets and antique shows, searching for new additions to their collections. The only fee is the cost-of-entry, and you can reach many potential buyers in a single day. If you have just one or two magazines to sell, you can attend as a visitor: visit dealer booths and keep an eye out for buyers.

These resources will help you find flea markets and antique shows in your area:

Used bookstores and antique stores

You can sell your magazines directly to dealers, which could help you earn a quick sale but likely won’t net you the most cash, since they must profit from resale. Still, if you don’t want to go through the hassle of listing your magazines online, visiting flea markets and antiques shows, or waiting for your magazine to sell, you can probably cash in quickly at used bookstores and flea markets.

Try FleaQuest to find antique stores, and use IndieBound or Biblio to find independent used bookstores. AntiqueMalls.com is an excellent resource for finding antique malls. Trussel.com also has a nice list of bookstores by specialty.

Pawn shops

Some pawn shops will buy old magazines. Like dealers, they must profit from resale so you won’t get the most money for your collection. The trade-off is you’ll get fast cash – if your local pawn shop is an interested buyer.

Find pawn shops near you on PawnFyndr, PawnShops.net, and Pawn Shop Listings.

Your android phone might be worth more than you think. Find cash offers here here:

Private collectors

This will require some research, but could potentially net you the most money if you can find a buyer who desperately wants to add your magazines to their collection. Search for collectors by magazine title, celebrity, author, artist, photographer, band, movie franchise, sport, fashion, history, and other topics to find potential buyers, then reach out to them directly.

Another strategy is to search for relevant forums and Facebook groups. For example, you might search for “Life magazine collector forum” or “Elvis Presley collectors group.” Join any relevant forums and groups, place classifieds ads, check out the “wanted to buy” sections, and message collectors directly.

Sports Illustrated

Source: Pinterest

Magazine selling tips

These tips will help you get the most money for old magazines:

  • Keep magazines in pristine condition: store them in acid-free plastic and out of sunlight in dry, fair temperatures. As Ferry puts it, “Damp basements and overheated attics are the worst places to store these fragile paper items.”
  • Conduct your research: Do your best to understand what you have, what condition it is in, and what it might be worth before you try to sell it.
  • Have it appraised and certified: If your magazine is valuable, getting it certified by a respected authority can make it worth even more.
  • Know your buyers: Consider every possible reason someone might want to buy your magazine. Sorenson says: “A friend of mine sells books and magazines online. With magazines, in his descriptions he mentions several of those articles that he thinks might still be topical and includes many pictures of the visual aspects that might capture a buyer’s attention. Someone might buy an issue of Life because it has his birth date. Another person might buy that same issue because it has a cover picturing General MacArthur, while someone else might buy that same magazine because it as a nice color ad of an antique care that they have restored. Each one of those buyers might not pay the same price for what they want.”

Though it’s true most magazines are worth very little, it’s also true that even low-value magazines can add up; after all, a stack of 100 National Geographic issues valued at $5 each is still worth $500. Use the resources in this article to determine how much your magazines are worth and find buyers so you can turn Dad’s old stash into cash.

Previous:
Next:

X

Curious how much your phone is worth?